Our Story The Bagel Blog Gift Cards Join Gotham Loyalty Merch Coffee Sandwiches Accessability
Chicago Madison
Our Story The Bagel Blog Gift Cards Join Gotham Loyalty Merch Coffee Sandwiches Accessability
Chicago Madison
 

the best in the midwest. period.
new york style bagels

 
 
order online
 
 
 
 
BagelBanner4.jpg
 
IngredientsIcon.png

TRADITIONAL INGREDIENTS

we use the same ingredients AUTHENTIC bagel-makers have been using for decades

Authentic Bagels

Each bagel is carefully rolled
by hand using a method PASSED DOWN GENERATIONS dating back to 1906

inventive sandwiches

our sandwiches are loaded
with unique flavor combinations & fresh ingredients

 
 
 
 

the Menu

 
Meet the Bagels
Meet the Sandwiches
 
 
BagelSandwiches.jpg

Gotham Bagels are the best in the midwest, period.

Gotham Bagels was started in 2006 by a New Yorker with a dream - a dream of bringing authentic, delicious, New York-Style bagels to the Midwest!

Get the whole story
Gotham Bagels
 
Salad Gotham Bagels
 

Need More than a Dozen Bagels?

Cater with Gotham Bagels! We’ve got platters for every occasion, just make sure you don’t forget the cream cheese!

Madison
Chicago
Catering FAQ
 
 
green.png
In loving memory ofKenneth Scharf (1956-2021) pictured here with fellow Gotham Bagels co-founder Joe Gaglio.

In loving memory of
Kenneth Scharf (1956-2021)

Pictured here with fellow Gotham Bagels co-founder Joe Gaglio.

 

Locations 

we’ve got five locations. find the best bagels near you!

bagel briefing

check out our sunday blog for all things bagels.

faq

you’ve got questions? We’ve got answers!