madison menu
Bagels
Single Bagel
One perfect, hand-rolled bagel. Loose Bagels do not come sliced.
New York Dozen (13)
Choose 13 bagels.
Hand-Rolled Bagels
Plain
Sesame
Everything
Poppy
Cinnamon Raisin
Onion
Salt
Garlic
Honey Whole Wheat
Egg
Premium Bagels
Super Egg Everything
Pumpernickel
Calabrian Chili with Mozzarella & Parmigiano
Bialy
Cream Cheese
House-Whipped Cream Cheese
8 oz of your favorite flavor.
House-Made Cream Cheese
Plain
Scallion
Veggie
Scallion Tofutti
Mediterranean Olive
Jalapeno Garlic
Caper
Honey Tart Cherry
Chimichurri
Plain Tofutti
Premium Cream Cheese
Shishito Pepper
Scallion Gochujang
Smoked Salmon
Rosemary Feta
Other Spreads
Avocado
Curried Hummus with Za'tar
Butter
Sandwiches
Bagel & Cream Cheese
Your choice of bagel and cream cheese.
Lox & Cream Cheese
Lox & your choice of cream cheese.
Bacon, Egg, & Cheddar
Fried egg, aged cheddar, & thick cut bacon.
Spicy Italian Sausage, Egg, & Cheddar
Brighton Beach
Lox, caper cream cheese, greens, tomato, red onion, capers.
OMFG
Fried egg, aged cheddar, Nashville fried chicken, thick cut bacon, & Calabrian chili aioli.
Rocky's Deli
The return of a Gotham Original - Fried Egg, Thick Cut Bacon, Aged Cheddar, Potato Latke, Spicy Ketchup.
Luchador!
Scrambled Eggs, Chorizo, Provolone, Cotija, Guac, Radish, Onion/Cilantro, & Spicy Red Cabbage Slaw.
The "G"
Capocollo, egg, and cheddar.
The Tony Soprano
Meatball Parmigiano with Hot Giardineria, Rich Tomato Sauce and Fresh Mozzarella made in house.
Arthur Ave.
Scrambled Egg, Hot Sausage, Peppers, Onions, Fontina.
The Mensch
Egg whites, Hot smoked salmon, Avocado mash, Creamy cucumbers, greens, Tomato.
Egg & Aged Cheddar
Pastrami & Egg
Includes Gotham's Finest Pickle.
Traditional Egg Salad Sandwich
Traditional Egg Salad, Heirloom Tomato and Vitruvian Greens.
Smoked Ham, Gouda, & Egg
Fried Egg, Locally Smoked Ham, Aged Gouda, fried egg.
The Yellow C.A.B.
Cheddar, avocado, bacon, arugula, tomato & mayo.
Super Tuscan
Fried egg, Fresh Mozzarella, Heirloom Tomato, Vitruvian Greens, and Pesto.
Chicken Salad Sandwich
Arugula, tomato.
Traditional Tuna Fish
Arugula, tomato, & red onion.
Bronx Bomber
Piled High Calabrese Salami, La Quercia Prosciutto, Mortadella, Provolone, Greens, Tomato, Chicago Johnny's Hot Giardiniera.
Williamsburg Hot Pastrami
Piled high Hot Pastrami with NY STRONG mustard. Served with pickle and NY deli cole slaw.
Athenian
Gyro-Style Lamb, Greens, Tomato, Cucumber, Red Onion, Tzatziki.
Massapequa
Grilled herbed chicken breast, roasted local peppers, aged provolone, Greens and pesto.
The Original "V"
Vegan scallion cream cheese, poblano salad, tomato, arugula, & avocado. Includes Gotham's Finest Pickle.
The Amagansett
House Made Whitefish Salad, Vitruvian Baby Greens, Cucumber, Hot House Tomato, Red Onion.
Port Washington
Hot Smoked Salmon Salad, Avocado Mash, Tomato, Baby Greens, Citrus Vinaigrette.
Long Island
House-Roasted Turkey Breast, Fontina, Greens, Tomato, Mayo.
Vegan Westbury "B.L.T."
Roasted beets, herb vinaigrette, greens, tomato, crispy onions, and vegan aioli.
Items from the Deli can be ordered in 1/2 Pound increments. Check out our Catering Platters for your next get together.
Deli & Bulk
Thinly Sliced Lox
1/2 Pound or Pound. With capers and red onion.
Hot Smoked Salmon
Pastrami
Sold by the pound. Comes with NY strong mustard.
Gotham Pickles
NY Deli Coleslaw
Traditional Tuna Salad
Tasty house-made tuna salad. 8 oz.
Gotham Egg Salad
Delicious house-made egg salad. 8 oz.
Gotham Chicken Salad
House-made. 8 oz.
Gotham Whitefish Salad
House-made. 8 oz.
Bowtie Pasta Pesto Salad
House-made. 5 oz.
Gotham's Finest Roasted Red Peppers
8 oz.
LaQuercia Coppa Americano
Dry cured and thin sliced Coppa crafted in Iowa.
Free Range Brown Eggs
Carton of 6 large eggs.
30-Month Old Parmigiano-Reggiano
Sold by the pound.
Willow Creek Farms Bacon
10 to 12 oz. Breakfast Pack.
Nueske's Applewood Smoked Bacon
12 oz. Made in Wittenburg, Wisconsin.
La Quercia Prosciutto Americano
1 oz. Made from Berkshire Heritage pork raised outside without antibiotics.
Spreadable Spicy Salami (N'Duja)
6 oz. Tempesta brand, locally produced.
Fruit de Mer Wild Caught Anchovies
7 oz. Imported.
Vitruvian Farms Baby Green Mix
5 oz. Locally grown produce from McFarland, Wisconsin.
Zingerman's Pimento Cheese
A salty, tangy, spicy mix of Cabot Vermont Cheddar, Hellmann’s mayo, pimento peppers and spices.
Curried Hummus with Za'tar
Extras
Bag of Bagel Chips
Made in house.
Gotham Frozen Bagels
Better than others' fresh! 6 pack assorted. Please do not request flavors on frozen bagels; flavors fluctuate daily.
Freezer Bags
Eco-friendly 5-pack of freezer bags. Bio-based film derived from Sugar Cane. Each bag hold 6 NY bagels.
Joe Chips
Retro potato chips.
Big Bag of Lillie's Chips
5 oz.
Chili Rubbed Home Fries
Single or double order.
Traditional Matzo Ball Soup
Served Hot.
Spicy Chicken Tortilla Soup
With Cotija Cheese.
Potato Latke
A healthy pound (usually 5 or 6 latkes). Comes with sour cream.
Fresh Fruit Cup
10 oz. Pineapple, blueberries, and grapes.
Pasta
Cav. Giuseppe Cocco-Farfalle
17.6 oz. Product of Italy.
Busiante (Imported Sicilian Pasta)
Joey Bagels-Preferred dry pasta.
Mafaldine (Imported Sicilian Pasta)
Joey Bagels-Preferred dry pasta.
Calamarata (Imported Sicilian Pasta)
Joey Bagels-Preferred dry pasta.
Condiments & Seasonings
Maldon Sea Salt Flakes
8.5 oz. Imported from Maldon, United Kingdom.
Savani Sea Salt and Black Summer Truffle
Imported, 3.5 oz.
Dario Cecchini Sea Salt with Tuscan Herbs
Imported from Italy, 14.8 oz.
Hawaiian Alaea Sea Salt
Product of Hawaii, 6.5 oz.
Everything Spice
12 oz.
Mother in Law's Kimchi
Vegan, 16 oz.
Hot Giardiniera
Olive oil based, bold and smoky flavor. 16 oz.
Capers in Sea Salt
Imported.
The Brinery Sriracha
Traditionally fermented hot sauce. 8 oz.
St. Elmo Steak House Shrimp Cocktail Sauce
Very spicy. 12 oz.
Old Fashioned Mustard
Imported from France. 7 oz.
Local European-Style Butter
Unsalted. 1 pound. Greenwood, Wisconsin.
Red Sweet Pequillo Peppers
La Catedral De Navarra Red Sweet "Pequillo" Peppers. Organic. 8.1 oz.
Athina Greatest & Dirtiest Martini Onion
Grown 2 ft below ground. Imported from Greece. 1 pound.
Coffee
Collectivo Velo
12 oz Whole bean bag of Collectivo Coffee.
Collectivo Co-Optiva
12 oz Whole bean bag of Collectivo Coffee
Collectivo Maximillian
12 oz Whole bean bag of Collectivo Coffee
Collectivo Blue Heeler
12 oz Whole bean bag of Collectivo Coffee
Venizelos Caffeine-Free Strong Greek Coffee
8 oz. Imported from Greece.
Sweets
Big City Coffee Cake
Organic Banana Bread
A NY Delicatessen staple.
Babka for One
Babka Loaf
Traditional Rugelach
14 oz. bag. Certified Kosher and parve.
Traditional Hamantaschen
12 oz. box.
Black & White Cookies
Individually wrapped.
Coffee & Espresso
Serving Colectivo Coffee in iconic NYC Coffee Cups.
Strong Coffee
Cold Brew
Juices & More
Fresh Squeezed Juices
Orange, Grapefruit, Cranberry & Rosemary, Spicy Pineapple Mint.
Specialty Soda
Featuring Dr. Brown's sodas. 12oz cans.
Aqua Panna Water
Powerade
Coca-Cola Products
San Pellegrino Sparkling Mineral Water
San Pellegrino Fruit Soda
Tapuat Brewing Co. Kombucha
16 oz. Door County, Wisconsin.
Premium Sparkling Italian Fruit Juice
750 mL. Gavioli, imported from Italy.
Fiji Water Bottle
1 Liter bottle.
Better Box Water
1 Liter box.
Please order at least one day in advance to allow for preparation.
Catering
Astoria Platter
One Pound Hummus, 1 Pound Imported Sheep's Milk Greek Feta, One Pound Baba Ghanoush, One Pound Tabbouleh, Marinated Olives, Mixed Peppers, Warm Pita.
Riverside Park
NY Dozen®, 1 lb lox, 2-8oz spreads, Baby Greens, Tomato, Cucumber, Big City Pickles, Red onion, and capers.
Long Island
NY Dozen®, 1 lb. Traditional Tuna Salad, 1 lb. Traditional Chicken Salad, 1lb. Traditional Egg Salad, Tomatoes, Baby Greens, Red Onion, Big City Pickles and Gotham Finest Cole Slaw.
Brighton Beach
NY Dozen®, 1 lb Lox, 8 oz Hot Smoked Salmon, 8 oz Smoked Whitefish Salad, 2- 8 oz Spreads, Baby Greens, Red Onion, Tomatoes, Cucumber, Big City Pickles.
Williamsburg
NY Dozen®, 1lb Corn Beef, 1lb Pastrami, 1lb Smoked locally cured Ham, 8oz Deli Coleslaw, 4 oz Gotham Deli Mustard, & Big City Pickles.
Big City Fruit Platter
Pineapple - grapes - blueberries - cantaloupe
Joe to Go Coffee Service
Collectivo Coffee service for 12 people. Includes cups, cream, and sugar.
*Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of food borne illness. Menu items may contain or come into come into contact with wheat, eggs, peanuts, tree nuts, and milk.
mouth watering yet?
Get more details about our bagels or find your nearest location below for current availability and menu details.
