Gotham Loyalty
Getting started is easy.
Earn loyalty points & get rewarded in just a few quick steps.
Gotham Rewards is for our four Chicago shops and Lake Geneva. Our Madison shop isn't part of Gotham Rewards. Looking for news instead? That's our email list, a separate thing, open to every shop.
Choose Your Location
To get started, choose your favorite Chicago or Lake Geneva shop.
Order Online
Pre-order your breakfast or place your office catering order online.
Earn Points, Get Rewards
For every $150 you spend at our Chicago and Lake Geneva shops, you’ll unlock a $10 reward.
Sign Up
Ready to start earning rewards? Sign up by choosing your fav location at the link below!
Sign In
Look up your loyalty account balance quickly & easily! Choose the location you signed up with below to check your account now.
Not the same as Rewards
Get the good stuff
New sandwiches. Seasonal schmears. Local events. Shop openings. Collaborations. Catering ideas. And occasionally, free Gotham swag.
Our email list and Gotham Rewards are two different things. Rewards earns you $10 back at our Chicago and Lake Geneva shops; the email list is how we share what's new, and it's open to every shop, Madison included.
Give the gift of Gotham
Looking for a gift instead? Grab an e-gift card for any Gotham Bagels location.
Shop Gift Cards