The Scoop on Cream Cheese Flavors

Going to the bagel shop can be an exercise in decision-making under pressure. What flavor of cream cheese should I get? Is a tormenting question when faced with heaping displays of no less than 100 flavors of cream cheese. Why are there so many options?!

Read More
Sarah Kutz
Surprising Facts about Black & White Cookies

Imagine you walk into a deli–anywhere, not just New York City—and look at the display. Among the many arresting things that greet your eyes are those classic black and white cookies. Sticking out like some sort of sugary street sign with their contrasty ying-and-yang message: eat me and experience the duality of man!

Read More
Sarah Kutz
Are Bagels Healthy?

Are you really looking for a yes or no answer to this question? You won’t find one. The relationship between health and diet is an infinite web. What does healthy mean? Looking for an answer on what to eat is almost an information overload. While our answer is ultimately yes, bagels are healthy, you have to come to your own conclusions—you can’t just Google it. That being said, let’s highlight a few things that might inform your opinion.

Read More
Sarah Kutz
The Perfect Latte

If we asked you to describe the perfect latte right now, what would you say? How specific could you get? Maybe you don’t really know the breakdown of what goes into the drink you have everyday, and maybe that’s a good thing–maybe that’s a testament to how seamlessly it all comes together in the cup. Below are a few key aspects of what makes a supreme latte. 

Read More
Sarah Kutz
Egg on a Bagel

How do you like your eggs? On a bagel is the correct answer. You can’t get far in your search for the perfect breakfast without running into eggs or bagels. And together, they magnify each others deliciousness to new heights.

Read More
Sarah Kutz
Bagel Catering Guide

So you’ve decided you want bagels at your next get-together. Now what? How much cream cheese should you get? How many bagels? Read our tips and best practices here.

Read More
Sarah Kutz
Where Did the Dozen Come From?

The dozen, much like the day or the foot, might bother you. Why is it split into twelve? Why not ten? Doesn’t ten make more sense? Bakers everywhere abide by this number (or that mysterious baker’s variant of thirteen)—why?

Read More
Sarah Kutz
Gotham Bagels Stands With Ukraine

Gotham Bagels stands with Ukraine and will be donating 50% of our total Chicago sales Monday, March 7th through Wednesday, March 9th; guests of our Chicago locations can make a difference by simply ordering with us during those dates.

Read More
Lili Kryzanek
Support Black Organizations

Although this year’s Black History Month is coming to a close, that doesn't mean we can't continue to support Black organizations within our communities. This Black History Month, we’re highlighting Black organizations in Madison & Chicago, and encourage you to donate to their causes.

Read More
Lili Kryzanek
What's up with Frozen Bagels?

As the temperature outside drops, frost is on the brain. Many of us in the Midwest grew up on frozen bagels. While that’s intrinsically tragic… It does make some sense. And frozen bagels can work in a pinch—when you freeze the right product in the right way.

Read More
Sarah Kutz
Deli Pickles Forever

Have you noticed people are divided when it comes to pickles? Some (us) really love them, and some really hate them—it’s never just a non-issue. Regardless of whether you like or dislike them, however, you should definitely respect them.

Read More
Sarah Kutz
All about Tuna Salad

Tuna salad is a delightful combination of ingredients that has stood the test of time. Tuna, mayo, onion, celery, some spice. Classic recipes like this don’t get invented every day. We sincerely hope you cherish the tuna salad.

Read More
Sarah Kutz
If Superheroes Ate Bagel Sandwiches...

A good portion of people that walk through the doors assume Gotham Bagels is some type of batman-themed restaurant. It is not, in fact, a batman-themed restaurant. But if superheroes came in our store, what bagel sandwiches would they eat?

Read More
Sarah Kutz
Hand Rolled Bagels vs. Machine Rolled Bagels

While an essential part of baking is tradition—human hands in dough—there are a few different tools that make the craft more efficient and profitable to bakers. These tools and machines come with varying degrees of acceptance and outrage. The bagel machine, for example, is a controversial one.

Read More
Sarah Kutz
What's So Great about Madison, Wisconsin?

We interrupt your regularly scheduled program for an important announcement: Madison, WI is the best city in the Midwest. In the south-central section of the great state of Wisconsin in between two shimmering lakes there lies a truly unique and spectacular gem of a city.

Read More
Sarah Kutz