Bagel Briefing

Bagel Bar: How to Set One Up for Any Crowd

A tub of house-whipped scallion cream cheese on a wooden table, ready for a bagel bar

A bagel bar is a self-serve spread: sliced bagels, a few cream cheeses, lox and deli salads, and a board of toppings, so every guest builds their own. Plan on one bagel per person, three 8 oz tubs of cream cheese per dozen bagels, and at least half a pound of lox for every six bagels. Then set it up in the order people actually build a bagel.

It’s the easiest way we know to feed a holiday open house, an office morning or a Thanksgiving-weekend houseful of relatives. Nobody has to cook, picky eaters are covered, and it looks like a lot of effort for very little. Here’s how to do it right.

How many bagels do I need for a bagel bar?

One per person. Bagels are filling, and most people take one, maybe half of a second. That’s why our dozen is a New York Dozen: 13 bagels, a baker’s dozen, so a dozen covers 13 guests.

Everything else scales from the bagel count. The full rules are on our how much should I order guide, but here’s the short version:

For every… Plan on
Guest 1 bagel
Dozen (13) bagels 3 tubs (8 oz) of cream cheese, or 4 if your crowd loves cream cheese
Half dozen (6) bagels At least ½ lb of lox, more for lox lovers
Half dozen (6) bagels 3 tubs (8 oz) of tuna salad

Ordering for 25? That’s two dozen bagels (26), six to eight tubs of cream cheese, and lox and a deli salad split across the rest.

What goes on a bagel bar?

Think in four groups, and you’ll cover everyone from the plain-and-butter kid to the full-lox uncle.

1. The bagels. Mix it up, but lean classic. Plain, everything, sesame and poppy go fastest; add a sweet one (cinnamon raisin) and a hearty one (pumpernickel or honey whole wheat). Ask us to slice them; it saves you a cutting board and a lot of crumbs.

2. The spreads. Plain, scallion and veggie cream cheese are the core three. Add one sweet (strawberry or maple cinnamon in Chicago and Lake Geneva) and one vegan option. Right now our Chicago and Lake Geneva shops also have seasonal French onion and pumpkin pie cream cheese. In Madison, look at honey tart cherry, jalapeño garlic and the vegan plain and scallion. The full lineups are on the Chicago & Lake Geneva menu and the Madison menu.

3. The fish and deli. Lox is the headliner. Add a deli salad or two: traditional tuna salad and smoked whitefish salad are on both menus, and Chicago also has a roasted poblano salad. For a heartier spread, sliced pastrami or smoked turkey.

4. The toppings. Red onion, capers, tomato, cucumber and greens. In Chicago and Lake Geneva, a Box of Veggies (arugula, heirloom tomato, red onion and capers) covers a half dozen bagels, so you don’t have to slice a thing.

A dozen bagels in a clear Gotham Bagels branded bag

How do you set up a bagel bar so the line keeps moving?

Lay it out in the order people build a bagel: plates and napkins, bagels, spreads, fish and deli, toppings, then coffee at the far end or on its own table. A few things that help:

  • Two of everything for a big crowd. Past about 25 guests, set up the bar with access from both sides, or put out two tubs of each popular cream cheese at opposite ends.
  • A knife for every spread. One knife per tub, so the scallion doesn’t end up in the strawberry.
  • Label it. A folded card for each spread and salad saves a dozen “is this the veggie one?” questions. Mark anything vegan.
  • Coffee somewhere else. People with a full cup in one hand can’t build a bagel. A separate coffee station keeps the bagel line short.

How long can a bagel bar sit out?

Bagels are happy at room temperature all morning. The cream cheese, lox and deli salads aren’t. The FDA’s buffet guidance says to throw out perishables that have sat at room temperature for more than two hours, or one hour if it’s above 90°F. Keep cold foods at 40°F or colder, nestled on ice if they’ll be out a while.

The same guidance has two tips that make a bagel bar easier anyway. Put out small platters and refill from the fridge, and swap an empty dish for a fresh one instead of piling new food on top of old. Utah State University Extension says the same thing: serve from several small platters rather than one big one, and it points out how hard it is to keep food at a safe temperature on a buffet table. So keep half the cream cheese and lox in the fridge and bring out round two when the first round runs low.

How do I handle allergies and dietary needs?

Bagels are made with wheat, and sesame and poppy seeds go everywhere. Sesame is now one of the nine major food allergens the FDA recognizes, along with milk, eggs, fish, shellfish, tree nuts, peanuts, wheat and soy. Most of those are standard bagel bar ingredients. A few easy moves help:

  • Put seeded bagels at one end and the plain bagels at the other, each with their own tongs.
  • Set out at least one vegan spread, with its own knife.
  • Keep fish and deli salads on a separate plate from the cream cheeses.

One honest note: everything at Gotham is made in kitchens that also handle milk, eggs, fish, shellfish, tree nuts, peanuts, wheat, sesame and soy, so we can’t guarantee any item is allergen-free. If a guest has a serious allergy, ask us before you order. We don’t make gluten-free bagels.

A Gotham Bagels sandwich platter with bacon, egg and cheddar bagel sandwiches, wrapped and sliced in half on a black tray

Can I order a bagel bar instead of building one?

Yes, and it’s the move when the crowd is big or the morning is busy. Our catering platters are a bagel bar packed and ready to set out:

  • Riverside Park Platter (Chicago, Lake Geneva and Madison): a New York Dozen, 1 lb of lox, two 8 oz spreads, greens, tomato, cucumber, pickles, red onion and capers. That’s the classic lox bar, and it serves 13.
  • Westchester Platter (Chicago and Lake Geneva): 13 bagels with tuna salad, smoked whitefish salad, two spreads and all the fixings.
  • Bagel and Cream Cheese Platter (every market): nine bagels already spread with your choice of three combos, sliced in half. Serves 9.
  • Add-ons: half pans of scrambled eggs or bacon (serve 12) and a Box of Coffee (serves 10) in Chicago and Lake Geneva; coffee service for 12 in Madison. Hosting for Hanukkah? Chicago and Lake Geneva also have a Latke Platter.

Every platter’s price is on the Chicago & Lake Geneva catering page and the Madison catering page. There’s no order minimum.

How far ahead should I order?

Online ordering has no minimum notice, so smaller orders can often be scheduled for the same day. For 30 people or more, order at least a day ahead so we can bake for you. You can schedule up to 60 days out in Chicago and Lake Geneva, and up to 90 days out in Madison, which is handy for holiday parties that are already on the calendar. Choose pickup or delivery at checkout. Feeding the office every week? Set up a recurring office order.

Ready to build yours?

Count your guests, pick your bagels, and order the spread online for pickup or delivery from your nearest Gotham. You bring the plates and the people. We’ll handle the bagels.

Sources

  1. U.S. Food and Drug Administration - Serving Up Safe Buffets
  2. U.S. Food and Drug Administration - Food Allergies
  3. Utah State University Extension - Five Tips for Food Safety at Holiday Buffets

Choose your shop

Each shop takes its own online orders. Pick yours and we'll remember it.

Chicago

Wisconsin

Hours and details for every shop