Bagel Briefing
Bagel Delivery in Chicago and Wisconsin: How It Works
Yes, Gotham Bagels delivers. Every shop, from the four in Chicago (Gold Coast, Lakeview, South Loop and the Magnificent Mile) to Lake Geneva and Madison, takes online orders for delivery: pick delivery at checkout, enter your address, and the checkout tells you whether you’re in range. It works for one breakfast sandwich or a full office spread.
Here’s the rest of what you need to know.
Does Gotham Bagels deliver near me?
Probably, if you’re near one of our shops. Delivery runs from the shop itself, so the closest one is the one that brings it.
| Shop | Delivery area |
|---|---|
| Gold Coast | About 4 miles out: Gold Coast, Old Town, River North, Streeterville, Lincoln Park, the Loop, West Loop |
| Magnificent Mile | About 4 miles out: Streeterville, River North, Gold Coast, the Loop, Old Town, Fulton Market, West Loop |
| South Loop | About 4 miles out: Printer’s Row, the Loop, Museum Campus, West Loop, Fulton Market, Chinatown, University Village |
| Lakeview | About 4 miles out: Lakeview, Southport Corridor, Lincoln Park, Wrigleyville, Roscoe Village, Bucktown, North Center |
| Lake Geneva | About 4 miles from the shop on Wrigley Drive: your house, lake house or hotel |
| Madison | The City of Madison, plus Middleton and Sun Prairie; anywhere else, call or email us |
Those neighborhoods are a guide, not a promise. The address check at checkout is the final word, and it also shows the delivery fee before you pay. Madison’s delivery charges are listed on the catering page.
How do I order bagel delivery?
Three steps, no phone call required:
- Open online ordering for your shop (every location page links to it).
- Choose delivery and enter the address, office or hotel.
- Build the order and pick a time: as soon as possible, or a scheduled time later.
In Chicago and Lake Geneva, online ordering opens when the shop opens, and you can schedule an order up to 60 days ahead. Madison takes online orders up to 90 days ahead. Mind the hours: the Chicago shops open at 6:30 a.m. and Lake Geneva at 7, the South Loop closes at 1 p.m. (Lake Geneva too on weekdays), and Madison is closed Mondays.
What can I get delivered?
Pretty much the whole menu. The usual delivery order looks like this:
- A bag of bagels. A NY Dozen® is 13 bagels, a true baker’s dozen, with house-whipped cream cheese on the side.
- Breakfast sandwiches. The Bacon, Egg & Cheddar, the Spicy Sausage, Egg & Cheddar, the Rocky’s Deli with a potato latke tucked in.
- Deli and lunch sandwiches, lox, deli salads and something sweet: a black and white cookie at every shop, plus babka and rugelach in Madison.
- Coffee. Passion House in Chicago and Lake Geneva, JBC Coffee Roasters in Madison.
Chicago and Lake Geneva share a menu; Madison has its own. See the Chicago & Lake Geneva menu and the Madison menu before you build the order.

Can I get bagel catering delivered to the office?
Yes, and it’s what a lot of our delivery orders are. Bagel and deli platters come with a NY Dozen and serve 13. The Sandwich Platter (nine sandwiches, wrapped and sliced in half) and the Bagel and Cream Cheese Platter each serve 9. In Chicago, add a half pan of scrambled eggs or bacon (each serves 12) and a Coffee Box (serves 10). Madison’s JBC coffee service serves 12.
The planning rules are simple:
- How much: one bagel or one sandwich per person. Our how much to order guide does the math for any headcount.
- When: online ordering has no minimum notice, so smaller orders can often be scheduled for the same day. For 30 people or more, order at least a day ahead so we can bake for you.
- Minimums: there’s no order minimum. The only item minimum is the Boxed Lunch (6 boxes), which you order by phone or through the catering team.
- Changes: in Chicago and Lake Geneva, cancel at least 2 hours before the order’s delivery time. Madison orders are final four days before the event.
Offices that order every week can set up recurring orders and, in Chicago and Lake Geneva, a house account. Start at office catering, or go straight to breakfast catering in Chicago.

How long can delivered bagels and cream cheese sit out?
Plain bagels are fine on the table all morning. The spreads are a different story. Cream cheese, lox and deli salads are perishable, and the FDA’s guidance for a buffet is to discard perishables left at room temperature for more than 2 hours, or 1 hour if it’s above 90°F. The same page says to keep cold food at 40°F or colder and hot food at 140°F or warmer.
For a long meeting, that means:
- Put the cream cheese and lox in the fridge until people are ready, then set them out.
- Set cold platters on ice if the spread will be out a while, as the FDA suggests.
- Swap a nearly empty tray for a fresh one instead of topping it off.
- Schedule the delivery close to start time rather than an hour early.
What’s the best way to store leftover delivered bagels?
Not in the fridge. Bread goes stale because its starch loses its hold on water, and Indiana Public Media’s A Moment of Science explains that this happens fastest at refrigerator temperatures and slowest below freezing. An NDSU Extension food and nutrition specialist puts it plainly: refrigerated bread goes stale six times faster than bread at room temperature, while freezing delays staling, with good quality for about three months.
So eat today’s leftovers today or tomorrow (kept in a bag on the counter), and freeze the rest. Slice them first, so they go straight from the freezer into the toaster. More ideas in what to do with day-old bagels.
Is delivery better than pickup?
Depends on the morning. Delivery is the move for the office, the lake house or a Sunday in sweatpants. If you’re walking past a shop anyway, order ahead for pickup and grab it at the counter; the Gold Coast shop even has loading zones out front for quick stops.
Get it on the way
Pick your closest shop on the locations page, choose delivery, and put your address in. Feeding a crowd? Start with catering, and we’ll bring the bagels, the schmear and the coffee.
Our shops
Hungry after all that reading? Our four Chicago shops, each with its own page.
