Bagel Briefing

Coffee Near Me? Local Roasts With a Fresh Bagel

A hand holding a hot coffee in a Gotham Bagels cup sleeve

If you’re searching “coffee near me” in Chicago, Lake Geneva or Madison, there’s a Gotham Bagels close by pouring local craft coffee: Passion House Coffee Roasters, roasted in Chicago, at our four Chicago shops and in Lake Geneva, and JBC Coffee Roasters, roasted in Madison, at our Madison shop. The bonus is a hand-rolled, kettle-boiled New York bagel to go with it, and you can order both ahead for pickup or delivery.

You’re in good company. The National Coffee Association found that two-thirds of American adults drink coffee every day, more than drink tea, juice, soda or bottled water. Here’s where to get a good cup from us, and what to order when you do.

Where can I get coffee near me in Chicago?

We have four Chicago shops, and every one has a full coffee and espresso bar:

Shop Where Hours Good to know
Magnificent Mile 162 E Superior St., half a block off Michigan Ave Daily 6:30 am – 2 pm On the Streeterville commute, a block from the Northwestern medical campus
Gold Coast 1212 N Dearborn St. Daily 6:30 am – 2 pm About 30 seats, a five-seat coffee bar and a covered, heated patio
Lakeview 2801 N Lincoln Ave. Daily 6:30 am – 2 pm Seats for about 20, a coffee bar and a patio
South Loop 521 S Dearborn St., Printer’s Row Daily 6:30 am – 1 pm A café area for laptop work

All four pour Passion House: the Night Moves Blend as hot coffee, Passion House cold brew, and Bassline espresso in the lattes.

Is there a good coffee shop in Lake Geneva?

Yes. Gotham Bagels Lake Geneva is at 300 Wrigley Drive in Harbor Shores, across the street from Geneva Lake and the Shore Path, and it’s open daily from 7 am, until 1 pm on weekdays and 2 pm on weekends. Lake Geneva shares the Chicago menu, so it’s the same Passion House coffee, the same espresso drinks and the same bagels. Grab a cold brew before a walk on the Shore Path, or a dozen bagels and a Box of Coffee for the lake house.

Where can I get coffee near me in Madison?

At the original Gotham, a block off Capitol Square at 112 E Mifflin St. Madison pours JBC Coffee Roasters, roasted right here in Madison: a six-time Good Food Award winner that Forbes named one of the 12 best coffee roasters in the U.S. Order the Strong Coffee in light or dark roast, served hot in iconic NYC coffee cups, or an iced coffee. You can also take home a 12 oz bag of JBC Black Earth whole bean coffee, with notes of praline, vanilla and dark chocolate.

Madison keeps its own hours: Tuesday through Saturday 8 am to 2 pm, Sunday from 8 am until we run out (usually noon), and closed Mondays.

A bagel sandwich with two Gotham coffees and tubs of house cream cheese on a café table

What coffee drinks can I order?

In Chicago and Lake Geneva, the menu runs from the basics to the house specials:

  • The basics: hot coffee, cold brew, espresso, Americano, cappuccino, latte and mocha.
  • House favorites: the Sweet Cream Cold Brew (Passion House cold brew topped with our sweet cream) and the Sweet Cream Matcha Latte.
  • Specialty lattes: a Pumpkin Spice Latte this time of year, a S’Mores Latte, and The Bee’s Knees, with lavender and honey. Add honey, vanilla, cinnamon or other syrups to a regular latte, and ask the barista about seasonal flavors.
  • Not coffee: chai and matcha lattes, organic Rishi tea, house-brewed iced tea and fresh lemonade.

Madison’s menu keeps it simple: strong JBC coffee, hot or iced, plus fresh-squeezed juice.

Is cold brew less acidic than hot coffee?

Not by as much as people think. A 2018 study from Thomas Jefferson University chemists found hot and cold brews had comparable pH, while the hot brews had more total titratable acids and higher antioxidant activity. So order cold brew because you like how it tastes, and hot coffee because you like that. Both are on the menu in Chicago and Lake Geneva.

How much coffee is too much?

For most healthy adults, the FDA cites 400 milligrams of caffeine a day, about two to three 12-ounce cups of coffee, as an amount not generally associated with negative effects. The FDA also notes that people vary widely in how sensitive they are to caffeine. If you’re near your limit, a chai latte, a matcha latte or a lemonade still makes good company for a bagel.

Can I order coffee for a meeting or a group?

Yes, and this is where a bagel shop beats a coffee shop: the coffee and the breakfast come in one order.

  • Chicago and Lake Geneva: a Box of Coffee serves 10 and comes with cups, sugars, creamers and stirrers.
  • Madison: the Joe to Go Coffee Service is JBC coffee for 12, with cups, cream and sugar.

Pair it with a platter. Bagel and deli platters come with a NY Dozen® (13 bagels, a baker’s dozen) and serve 13; the Sandwich Platter and the Bagel and Cream Cheese Platter serve 9. Order online for pickup or delivery. There’s no order minimum, and online ordering has no minimum notice, so smaller orders can often be scheduled for the same day; for a big order, place it at least a day ahead. Chicago and Lake Geneva orders can be scheduled up to 60 days out, and Madison up to 90. The catering page has the full menus and current prices, and office catering covers recurring orders and house accounts.

Four hands toasting with cups of black coffee and orange juice, seen from above

How do I skip the line?

Order ahead. Every location page links to that shop’s online ordering: pick your coffee and a bagel, choose pickup or delivery, and choose a time. In Chicago and Lake Geneva, online ordering opens when the shop opens.

Grab a cup

Find your nearest shop on our locations page and order a coffee and a bagel for pickup. Feeding a room? Start with a Box of Coffee and a platter from our catering menu.

Sources

  1. U.S. Food and Drug Administration - Spilling the Beans: How Much Caffeine Is Too Much?
  2. National Coffee Association - More Americans Drink Coffee Each Day Than Any Other Beverage
  3. Rao and Fuller, Scientific Reports (2018) - Acidity and Antioxidant Activity of Cold Brew Coffee

Choose your shop

Each shop takes its own online orders. Pick yours and we'll remember it.

Chicago

Wisconsin

Hours and details for every shop