MADISON breakfast, bagels, Bagel Sandwiches, and Deli Menu

Bagels↓

Loose bagels do not come sliced

• Plain
• Sesame
• Everything
• Poppy
• Cinnamon Raisin
• Onion
• Salt
• Honey Whole Wheat
• Egg
• Super Egg Everything
• Pumpernickel

Cream Cheese Spreads↓

8oz Containers

• Plain Cream Cheese
• Scallion Cream Cheese
• Veggie Cream Cheese
• Smoked Salmon Cream Cheese
• Honey Tart Cherry Cream Cheese
• Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese
• Mediterranean Olive Cream Cheese
• Jalapeno/Garlic Cream Cheese
• Caper Cream Cheese
• Chimichurri Cream Cheese
• Tofu Plain
• Whipped Feta, Rosemary and Cracked Black Pepper Cream Cheese

• Seasonal Flavor: Charred Asparagus Parmigiano Cream Cheese

Bagel Sandwiches↓

• Bagel
  • with cream cheese
• Bacon, Egg and Cheddar
  • Fried egg, aged cheddar, thick cut bacon, choice of bacon
• Lox & Cream Cheese
  • Choice of bagel with lox and cream cheese
• OMFG
  • Fried egg, aged cheddar, thick cut bacon, Nashville fried chicken, Calabrian chili aioli
• Heritage Ham, Gouda and Egg
  • Heritage ham, aged Gouda, and fried egg
• Bronx Bomber
  • Piled high Calabrese salami, La Quercia prosciutto, mortadella, Provolone, Vitruvian Farms baby creens, tomato, Chicago Johnny's hot giadineria
• Brighton Beach
  • Lox, caper cream cheese, Vitruvian farms greens, tomato, red onion, capers
• Athenian
  • Gyro "Style" lamb, Vitruvian Farms greens, tomato, cucumber, red onion, tzatziki
• The Long Island
  • House-roasted turkey breast, fontina, Vitruvian Market greens, tomato, mayo
• Traditional Tuna Fish
  • Arugula, tomato, red onion, choices of bagel, Gotham's Finest pickle
• Pastrami and Egg
  • Choice of bagel
• Piled High Pastrami
  • Piled high hot pastrami with NY STRONG mustard and a pickle spear
• Massapequa
  • Grilled herbed chicken breast, roasted red pepper, aged provolone, Vitruvian Farms baby greens and pesto
• The Yellow C.A.B.
  • Cheddar, avocado, bacon, Vitruvian Farms greens, tomato and mayo
• Piled High Cornbeef
  • NY STRONG mustard
• The Port Washington
  • Hot smoked salmon salad, avocado mash, Flyte Farm tomato, Vitruvian baby greens, citrus vinaigrette
• The Original V
  • ...The one, The Only, The greatest VEGAN sandwich in Madison! Scallion tofutti, poblano salad, avocado, tomato, Vitruvian baby greens
• The Fire Island
  • Jumbo Shrimp Salad, Vitruvian Baby Greens, Tomato, lemon/chili mayo
• The Super Tuscan
  • EGG, fresh Mozzarella, Tomato, Vitruvian Greens, Pesto
• The Arthur Avenue
  • Fried Egg, Hot Italian Rope Sausage, Peppers, Onions, Fresh Mozzarella
• Gertrude Stein Egg Salad Sandwich
  • Vitruvian Farms Arugula, Tomato, Big City Pickle, choice of Bagel
• The Luncheonette
  • GOTHAM Chicken Salad, Vitruvian Farms Arugula, Tomato
• The Montauk Lobster Salad
  • GOTHAM Lobster Salad, Vitruvian Farms Baby Greens, Tomato, Guacamole

Sides & More ↓

• Kettle Chips
• Bag of Bagel Chips
• Chili Rubbed Home Fries
  • Single or double order
• Potato Latke
  • A healthy pound (usually 5 or 6) Comes with sour cream
• One Dozen Bagels *Your choice of 13 bagels. Loose bagels do not come sliced
• Bialy
• Alaskan Smoked Salmon Lox by the Pound
  • Vitruvian Baby Greens, Tomato, Red Onion, Capers
• Traditional Babka, 24oz Loaf
  • Certified Kosher and Parve, Chocolate or Cinnamon
• Traditional Rugelach, 14oz Bag
  • Certified Kosher and Parve
• Traditional Hamantaschen, 12oz Box
  • Certified Kosher and Parve
• Traditional Matzo Ball Soup
  • Choice of quart or pint
• Hot Soup
  • Choice of quart or pint
• Big City Coffee Cake
• Juniors Famous New York Cheese Cake *Certified Kosher and Parve
• Gotham Grocery Box
  • 3-8oz Wagyu beef patties, 4-bratwurst, 4-uncured hot dogs, Any dozen bagels with spreads, NY Deli Salads, 8oz each: Macaroni, Potato, Roasted Red Peppers, Coleslaw, Gotham's Finest pickles, Chicago Jonny's hot Giardiniera and 32oz Sucker Punch Bloody Mary Mix
• Jumbo Shrimp Salad
  • Lemon/Chili Mayo
• Gotham Frozen Bagels
  • Better than others fresh 6 pack assorted

Deli & Bulk↓

• Gotham's Finest Roasted Red Peppers
  • 8oz container
• Pastrami by the Pound
  • NY Strong Mustard
• Gotham Chicken Salad
  • 8oz or 1lb container
• Gotham Smoked Whitefish Salad
  • 8oz or 1lb container
• Traditional Tuna Salad
  • 8oz or 1lb container
• Golden Greek Peppers (Pepperoncini)
• Gotham's Finest Pickles
• Sunday Sauce Dinner (Feeds 2 to 3)
  • 16 oz. of Sunday Sauce, 1 # Giuseppe Coco pasta and 8 oz. of Reggiano Parmigiano
• 100% Sheep's Milk Feta in Brine
  • 8oz slab Oregano, extra virgin olive oil dressing
• Willow Creek Farms Bacon
  • 10 to 12oz breakfast pack
• White Tuna in Olive Oil
  • Imported from Spain 3.5oz
• La Quercia Prosciutto Americano
  • Made from Berkshire Heritage pork outside with antibiotics, 2oz
• Despana Traditional Chorizo
  • Fully cookied and gluten-free, 4 links 12oz
• Marinated White Anchovies
  • Sunflower oil. Imported from Spain 3.8oz
• New York Deli coleslaw
  • 1 lb
• Imported Kefalograviera Cheese, 1.1 lbs
  • Perfec for making Saganaki (Greek Flaming Cheese)
• Hot Smoked Salmon
  • Ewig Smokehouse, Port Washington, WI
• Nueske's Applewood Smoked Bacon, 12oz
  • Made in Wittenberg, Wisconsin
• Gorgonzola Gnocchi
  • 12.4oz No boil, gmo free
• Olympia Soppressata
  • 4oz
• Spreadable Spicy Salami (N'Duja)
  • Tempesta brand, locally produced
• Finocchiona Uncured Fennel Pollen Salamni
  • Tempesta brand, locally produced
• Chef Martin's Old World Sausage
  • 4 Links, 10oz, locally produced
• Mother in Law's Kimchi
  • Vegan, 16oz
• The Brinery Sriracha
  • Traditionally Fermented Hot Sauce 8oz
• Ny Delicatessen Salads
  • Mayonnaise based, 8oz

Gotham Grocery↓

• Can of Nutkrack
  • Caramelized, buttery, toasted pecans and sea salt. Locally made.
• Athina Greek Tahini
  • 100% Ground Sesame Seeds. One Pound Jar. Imported, 16oz
• Athina Stuffed Eggplant
  • Imported baby eggplant stuffed with red peppers, 16oz
• Athina Kalamata Olive Paste
  • 16oz jar, imported. Extra Virgin Olive oil added
• Athina Honey
  • Pure, natural. Imported, Greece, 16oz
• Athina Greatest and Dirtiest Martini Onion Greece
  • Grown 2 ft below ground, 1lb
• Imported Dolmas
  • 10-12 grape leaves stuffed with rice, lemon dressing
• Box of 14 Evolv LifeBars
  • Choice of flavor: Sweet and salty caramel, dark chocolate, chocolate mint, blueberry pomegranate
• Individual Evolv LifeBars
  • Choice of flavor: Sweet and salty caramel, dark chocolate, chocolate mint, blueberry pomegranate
• 2-Pack of Tork 2-Ply Extra Large Toilet Paper Rolls
• Savani Superior Truffle Oil
  • 3.4oz
• Capers in Sea Salt
• Cav. Giuseppe Cocco - Fettucine
  • 17.6oz, product of Italy
• Cav. Giuseppe Cocco - Farfalle
  • 17.6oz, product of Italy
• Cav. Giuseppe Cocco - Mezzi Rigatoni
  • 17.6oz, product of Italy
• Hot Giardiniera
  • Olive oil based, bold and smoky flavor, 16oz
• Vitruvian Farms Baby Greens Mix, 5oz
  • Locally grown produce, McFarland, Wisconsin
• 6 large free range brown eggs
• Sicilian Extra Virgin Olive Oil
  • 1 Liter
• Premium Spanish Extra Virgin Olive Oil
  • OMED Brand, 1 Liter
• First Cold Press Olive Oil
  • 1 Liter
• Masserie Cold Extracted Extra Virgin Olive Oil
  • Imported from Italy, 250 ml
• Five Liter Extra Virgin Olive Oil
  • Cold pressed imported from Italy
• Dario Cecchini Extra Virgin Olive Oil
  • Cold pressed, small batch, imported, 16.9oz
• My Big Fat Greek Jar of Capers
  • 16oz
• Maldon Sea Salt Flakes
  • Imported from Maldon, United Kingdom, 8.5oz
• Arborio Italian Rice
  • 1lb, perfect for pudding
• Carnaroli Italian Rice
  • The Risotto Workhorse Imported, Italy
• Quick Cook Polenta
  • Imported from Italy
• Toasted Fregola (Semolina Pasta)
  • Made from hard grain, imported Italy, 1.1lb
• Savani Black Summer Truffle Butter
  • Imported, 2.8oz
• Chianti Classico Region Extra Virgin
  • DOP certification, 16.9oz
• Caponi Handmade Egg Tagliatelle
  • Imported 8.8oz
• Spaghetti superior bronze die semolina pasta
  • Imported, 1.1lb
• Calamaretti Superior Bronze Die Semolina Pasta
  • Imported, 1.1lb
• One Family One Crop One Linguine
  • Small family farm, imported 17.6oz
• Italian Wildflower Honey
  • From Nomadic Beekeepers 8.8oz
• Caponi Handmade Gluten Free Pasta
  • Made from Rice, imported 8.8oz
• Pure 8 year old balsamic vinegar
  • Estate bottled, 100% pure 3.37oz
• Savani Sea Salt and Black Summer Truffle
  • Imported, 3.5oz
• Flyte Family Farm Beefsteak Tomatoes
  • Grown in Coloma, WI 1lb
• Suckerpunch Spicy Bloody Mary Mix, 32oz
• Spanish Smoked Paprika
  • Imported, 2.6oz*
• Sugar Coated Chickpeas
  • Imported, 1lb*
• La Guinelle Vinaigre de Banyuls - Banyuls Vinegar
  • Imported France, 500ML
• Dario Cecchini Sea Salt with Tuscan Herbs
  • Imported Italy, 14.8oz
• Sea Salt From Greece
  • 7oz shaker
• Sicilian Oregano on Branches
  • 25g, Imported
• Sun Kissed Cherry Tomatoes
  • Imported Italy, DeCarlo, In Extra Virgin Olive Oil, 6.7oz
• Cerignola Green Olives
  • DeCarlo, Imported, 580g
• Vitruvian Farms Heirloom Tomatoes
  • Locally grown, McFarland. WI. $5.50 per pound
• Oritz Piquillo Peppers Stuffed with Tuna
  • 330g, Imported Spain
• Collectivo Co Optiva
  • coffee grounds 1lb
• Collectivo Costa Rica
  • coffee grounds 1lb
• Collectivo Vela
  • coffee grounds 1lb
• Collectivo Maximilan Brand
  • coffee grounds 1lb
• Venizelos Strong Greek Coffee
  • Imported Greece, coffee grounds 16oz
• Venizelos Caffeine Free Strong Greek Coffee
  • Imported Greece, coffee grounds 8oz
• Mieli Italian Hazelnut Honey
  • Nomadic Beekeepers, 8.8oz
• Red Boat Fish Sauce
  • Imported Vietnam, 250ml
• Imported Orzo
  • Imported Greece, perfect for chicken soup, 17.6oz
• Badia a Coltibuono Red Wine Vinegar
  • 16.9oz floor oz, product of Italy

Beverages↓

• Dr. Brown's Soda
• Snapple
• Aqua Panna Water
• Powerade
• Fresh Squeezed Juice
• Coca Cola Products
  • Canned
• San Pellegrino Sparkling Mineral Water
• San Pellegrino Refreshing Fruit Soda
• Strong Coffee *Colectivo Coffee, served Hot in iconic NY Coffee Cups
• Tapuat Brewing Co. Kombucha
• RISHI Tea Packs
• Chilled Vanilla Latte
• Evian Sport Bottle
• Premium Sparkling Fruit Juice