Bagel Briefing
Sandwiches Near Me? A Deli Lunch on a Real Bagel
If you’re searching “sandwiches near me” or “lunch near me” in Chicago or southern Wisconsin, Gotham Bagels makes deli sandwiches at six shops: Gold Coast, Lakeview, South Loop and the Magnificent Mile in Chicago, plus Lake Geneva and Madison. Pastrami, smoked turkey, tuna, whitefish and vegan, all on a bagel we hand-roll, kettle-boil and bake that day. Walk in, order ahead for pickup, or get it delivered.
One thing to know up front: we’re a morning-and-lunch shop, so we close in the early afternoon. Here’s how to make it work.
Where can I get a sandwich for lunch near me?
Pick the closest shop and check the clock. Holiday hours are posted on every location page.
| Shop | Where | Lunch until |
|---|---|---|
| Magnificent Mile | 162 E Superior St., Chicago | 2pm daily |
| Gold Coast | 1212 N Dearborn St., Chicago | 2pm daily |
| Lakeview | 2801 N Lincoln Ave., Chicago | 2pm daily |
| South Loop | 521 S Dearborn St., Chicago | 1pm daily |
| Lake Geneva | 300 Wrigley Dr., Lake Geneva, WI | 1pm weekdays, 2pm weekends |
| Madison | 112 E Mifflin St., Madison, WI | 2pm Tue–Sat; Sunday until sold out; closed Monday |
The South Loop and weekday Lake Geneva close at 1, so an early lunch is the move there. Everywhere else, you’ve got until 2.
Which Gotham sandwiches are made for lunch?
Breakfast sandwiches get a lot of the glory, but half the menu is deli. Chicago and Lake Geneva share one menu; Madison has its own.
Chicago and Lake Geneva:
- The Williamsburg. Pastrami, NY strong mustard and coleslaw. The deli classic.
- The Long Island. Smoked natural turkey breast, fontina, arugula, heirloom tomato and mayo.
- Traditional Tuna Fish. Our house tuna with arugula, heirloom tomato and red onion.
- The Amagansett. Smoked whitefish salad, arugula, cucumber, heirloom tomato and red onion.
- The Yellow C.A.B. Bacon, cheddar, avocado, arugula, heirloom tomato and mayo.
- The V. Vegan scallion cream cheese, roasted poblano salad, heirloom tomato, arugula and avocado.
- Brighton Beach. Cold-smoked salmon, cream cheese, heirloom tomato, red onion, arugula and capers.
- Pizza Bagel. Served sandwich style, closed-faced, at the Chicago shops only.
This season there’s also a Turkey Artichoke special: creamy spinach artichoke spread, smoked turkey, heirloom tomato, pickled red onions and arugula.
Madison goes bigger on the deli side: the Williamsburg Hot Pastrami (with a pickle and NY deli coleslaw), the Woodlawn Corned Beef (ask to make it a Reuben), the Bronx Bomber with salami, prosciutto, mortadella, provolone and Chicago Johnny’s hot giardiniera, the Massapequa with grilled herbed chicken and pesto, the Tony Soprano meatball parm, plus chicken salad, tuna salad, whitefish and the Original “V.”

See everything on the Chicago & Lake Geneva menu and the Madison menu.
Why put a deli sandwich on a bagel?
Because pastrami and a bagel come from the same place. New York’s Jewish delis grew up alongside its bagel bakeries: historian Ted Merwin, interviewed by The World, dates the first Jewish deli in New York to 1888 and says the deli became a celebrated gathering place in the 1920s. Rye got the headlines. The bagel was right there on the counter.
There’s a practical reason too. A boiled, chewy bagel holds tuna salad, whitefish or a stack of turkey without going soggy by the time you’re back at your desk. Soft sandwich bread can’t say that. If you want the long version, read the art of the sandwich and our pastrami post.
How do I get lunch fast on a work day?
Order ahead. Every Gotham shop takes online orders for pickup or delivery, and your order goes straight to the kitchen. In Chicago and Lake Geneva, online ordering opens when the shop opens, so you can order lunch at 9 and pick it up at noon.

Can’t leave your desk? You’re not alone. The USDA’s analysis of the American Time Use Survey found that in 2023 people spent 16.4 minutes a day eating as a secondary activity, meaning while doing something else. Choose delivery at checkout and enter your address. The Chicago shops and Lake Geneva deliver to about four miles out, and the checkout tells you whether you’re in range. Madison delivers within the City of Madison and to Middleton and Sun Prairie. More on how it works in our bagel delivery guide.
In Chicago and Lake Geneva, add a side while you’re at it: Great Lakes kettle chips, a Gotham pickle, a Dr. Brown’s soda and a black and white cookie make it a proper deli lunch.
Can I order sandwiches for an office lunch?
Yes, and there are two easy ways to do it.
- The Sandwich Platter (every market): nine Gotham sandwiches, wrapped and sliced in half (18 halves). Choose three types and we make three of each. Serves 9.
- The Boxed Lunch (Chicago and Lake Geneva): one box per person with a sandwich, chips, a canned soda or water, and our brown butter chocolate chunk cookie. There’s a 6-box minimum, and for now boxed lunches are ordered by phone or through our catering team rather than online. Details on the Boxed Lunch page.
Plan on one sandwich per person; the how much should I order guide does the math. There’s no order minimum. Online ordering has no minimum notice, so smaller orders can often be scheduled for the same day, but for a big order, place it at least a day ahead. Chicago and Lake Geneva orders can be scheduled up to 60 days out, Madison up to 90. Start with office catering or Madison catering.
How long can a sandwich platter sit out?
Not all afternoon. The FDA’s buffet advice is to discard perishables left at room temperature for more than 2 hours, or 1 hour if it’s above 90°F, unless you keep them cold. Tuna, whitefish and lox count. Set the platter out when people arrive, put leftovers in the office fridge, and the 3pm crowd gets a second round.
The bottom line
The best sandwich near you is the one on a bagel that was rolled, boiled and baked that morning. Find your closest Gotham, order a Williamsburg on an everything before noon, and skip the line when you walk in. Feeding the whole team? Plan your catering and we’ll wrap it up.
Our shops
Hungry after all that reading? Find the Gotham nearest you.
